July 22, 2014

Oakland Council reaffirms composting policy

On March 18 the Oakland City Council adopted a resolution to implement new Waste Collection Franchise Policies.

This resolution requires bidders on the city’s waste-hauling contract and city staff to present viable options for mandatory source-separated composting services to all Oakland residents, including those in multi-family units. It also calls for family-supporting wages and bene­fits for recycling workers. These are ends that the Sierra Club Northern Alameda County Group has been actively working towards.


We  still do not know when the final waste-hauling contract will come back to the Council for a vote. At that time it will be important to make sure that full implementation of citywide compost service is included for all residences. So far the city has merely asked for a cost estimate; food-scrap collection service at no extra charge will only become a reality if city residents insist on it.

To make sure that you receive our alert when it is time to contact the Council again, go to http://action.sierraclub.org/site/PageNavigator/CHP_SFBay_SignUpThen sign up for “Updates and alerts from the SF Bay Chapter”.

Oakland in ferment over compost policy

220x220_zero-wasteSoon, likely before the next Yodeler appears, the Oakland City Council will decide on a 10 – 20-year waste-hauling contract, in particular on whether to provide a third bin for compost to all multi-unit buildings. This decision will be an important element in the city’s efforts to limit climate change.

According to StopWaste’s 2008 Waste Characterization Study, around 43 – 53% of the waste from residential units in Alameda County is compostable organic matter. If not managed properly, compostables release a substantial amount of methane into the atmosphere. Methane is a powerful climate-disrupting gas, with 20 times the short-term impact of CO2. Not only is composting one of the most effective ways to control methane release, but it also helps to save on scarce landfill space.

We fear that Oakland’s leadership is wavering on providing a third bin for compost to multifamily units–which represent a growing proportion, now 40%, of Oakland’s residents.

Without a third bin people throw compostables in the trash. This mix of food scraps and rubbish will go to a Multi-Reuse Facility (not yet built) to be separated via screens and then by recycling workers. At best this method produces low-grade contaminated compost with limited uses. Another key contract concern is to improve the wages for Oakland’s recycling workers, who are doing our dirty work (see the article on page 7 about the big raise for Fremont recycling workers). Today most Oakland recyclers do not even make living wages (starting wage is $12.75/hour), and they work under hazardous conditions to sort the trash we throw out. It’s time to be conscious of what we throw away and whom it affects.

Composting in multi-unit buildings can be challenging and will take time and effort to implement. San Francisco set an example by launching a successful citywide third-bin composting program with an intensive educational campaign, empowering residents to be responsible for their waste and environmental footprint. Now, only five years later, San Francisco has participation by hundreds of thousands of residents.

Climate change is the defining issue of our time and permeates every layer of our day-to-day lives. A huge part of moving towards Zero Waste is helping people to become conscious of their waste. In-home composting does this better than having low-paid recycling workers sort our trash for us. Everyone deserves the equal opportunity to take responsibility for their environmental footprint, and this education is essential to our transition towards sustainable city living.

What You Can Do

E-mail your Oakland councilmember (you can find your Council district at http://mapgis.oaklandnet.com/councildistricts), with copies to city administrator Deanna Santana at dsantana@oaklandnet.com, Mayor Jean Quan at jquan@oaklandnet.com, and Public Works Agency Director Brooke Levin at blevin@oaklandnet.com.

Or write to each of these at:

Oakland City Hall
1 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza
Oakland, CA 94612.

Urge them to make sure that the new Zero Waste contract includes a mandatory third-bin for compostables for all Oakland residents, including multiunit buildings, and fair wages for recycling workers.

When the contract comes to the City Council for approval, we will need you to take action again. To be notified then, sign up for the Sierra Club Bay Chapter’s e-mail updates and alerts at http://action.sierraclub.org/site/PageNavigator/CHP_SFBay_SignUp.

Fremont votes big raises for recycling workers

Fremont recycling worker Maria Navarro has been supporting her children on low wages for the past five years. She and others brought their children to ask the City Council for better pay. Photo courtesy International Longshore and Warehouse Union.

Fremont recycling worker Maria Navarro has been supporting her children on low wages for the past five years. She and others brought their children to ask the City Council for better pay. Photo courtesy International Longshore and Warehouse Union.

On Dec. 10 the Fremont City Council approved a fee increase to provide for a wage increase for 65 workers at the Fremont transfer station. Over six years, sorters’ wages will increase from $13.90 per hour to $20.94 per hour. Other workers will receive similar wage increases.

While workers’ wages will rise significantly, rates for Fremont rate payers will increase by only about $.32 per month. This shows that when a city, its service provider, and workers and their union all work together, it is possible to solve the problem of poverty wages in the recycling industry.

As participants in the Alameda Sustainable Recycling Campaign, the Sierra Club Bay Chapter hopes that Fremont will serve as a model for other communities in Alameda County, particularly Oakland. On Dec. 17, 24 recycling workers attended the Public Works Committee meeting in Oakland to show support for including a wage-and-benefits standard in the Oakland franchise agreement.

Recycling workers employed by BLT in Fremont are members of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union Local 6. They’re working with the Sierra Club and other groups to improve pay and services in the recycling industry--part of an effort to achieve Zero Waste.

Recycling workers employed by BLT in Fremont are members of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union Local 6. They’re working with the Sierra Club and other groups to improve pay and services in the recycling industry–part of an effort to achieve Zero Waste.

Workers Jose Romero and Yadira Carrasco thanked Councilmembers Gallo and Kalb for their public support of their campaign and urged all councilmembers to work to include a standard in the contract.

Ruth C. Abbe, Sierra Club Bay Chapter Zero Waste Committee

Alameda County sustainable-recycling campaign gains momentum

220x220_zero-wasteThe Sierra Club has partnered with labor organizations, faith-based groups, and other environmental and community-based non-profits to launch the Alameda County Sustainable Recycling Campaign. We formed this campaign to work toward the shared goals of reaching Zero Waste, elevating the status and working conditions of recycling workers, and creating more good green jobs in Alameda County.

The campaign has advocated for food-scrap collection services for residents of multi-family housing in Oakland (see April-May 2013, page 3), and supported rate increases to pay for better wages and benefits for recycling workers in Fremont. Both of these issues are still undecided. Fremont implements its biennial rate adjustment in January, and so its City Council will consider the rate increase at its Dec. 3 meeting.   Newark and Union City, which also use the Fremont facility, are expected to vote on their own increases later in 2014. The final Oakland waste-hauling contract will return to City Council for final approval, perhaps as soon as January.

On Nov. 9 the campaign hosted a community and worker recycling forum to ask Oakland councilmembers to pledge to support the social and environmental goals of the campaign.


Contact Oakland councilmembers:

Dan Kalb, District 1

Pat Kernighan, District 2

Lynette Gibson McElhaney, District 3

Libby Schaaf, District 4

Noel Gallo, District 5

Desley Brooks, District 6

Larry Reid, District 7

Rebecca Kaplan, at large

Ask them to sign on to the pledge to protect the environment, strive for Zero Waste, and support recycling workers. Tell them you support recycling and composting services for everyone.

Ruth Abbe, Sierra Club Bay Chapter Zero Waste Committee

Community and Worker Recycling Forum: support good green recycling jobs, not junk jobs!

sorterSaturday, November 9, 2 – 4 pm, La Primera Iglesia Presbiteriana Hispana, 1941 High Street, Oakland.

Recycling workers are the backbone of Alameda County’s environmental efforts to promote recycling and reduce our reliance on landfills.

Most recycling workers, the majority of whom are immigrants, earn on average less than $13/hour and are struggling to provide for their families while facing hazardous conditions on the job. Last year, a worker was even killed at the Transfer and Processing Facility in San Leandro operated by Waste Management.

Come tell Oakland councilmembers: “We want good green jobs, not junk jobs!”

Oakland is finalizing lucrative 20-year, multi-million-dollar trash and recycling contracts. Help ensure that workers are paid family-supporting wages that value the important recycling work they perform!

To RSVP, please visit https://www.facebook.com/events/610045552371079/.

For more information and Spanish-language flyer, contact Jennifer Lin, East Bay Alliance for a Sustainable Economy (EBASE) at (510)893-7106, ext. 321, jenny@workingeastbay.org.

Members of the Campaign for Sustainable RecyclingEast Bay Alliance for a Sustainable Economy (EBASE) * Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (GAIA) * Faith Alliance for a Moral Economy (FAME) * International Longshore and Warehouse Union (ILWU) * ILWU Local 6 * Sierra Club San Francisco Bay Chapter * Ella Baker Center for Human Rights * Movement Generation Justice & Ecology Project * Mujeres Unidas y Activas (MUA) * Oakland Rising * Worksafe.

Chapter Zero Waste chair becomes state chair as well

220x220_zero-wasteDavid Haskell of Fairfax, chair of the Bay Chapter’s Zero Waste Committee for the last two years, has stepped in to chair the Sierra Club California Zero Waste Committee, while previous chair Ann Schneider takes a leave to run for Millbrae City Council. David, a Lassen County native and UC graduate, spent 30 years in New Zealand, where he served as director of New Zealand’s Waste Management Institute and group manager of the New Zealand Ministry of Energy Conservation Division. He’s been back in the states for 10 years, and is now senior partner of Haskell & Associate’s Renewable Energy Service Company operating out of Marin County.

Oakland Council advances composting

220x220_zero-wasteOn June 18 the Oakland City Council took a key vote, instructing city staff to come back with a cost estimate for providing collection services for food scraps and compostable paper (pizza boxes, paper napkins, paper plates) for all city residents, including apartments and other multi-unit buildings, in the final negotiations on the city’s recycling, compost, and trash-collection contract.

Providing compost (food scrap) collection is an important step towards the city’s goal of Zero Waste. No longer will valuable organics-rich materials be mixed in with the refuse going to landfill, and workers won’t have to do the inefficient, dangerous work of trying to separate out some of the compostable materials. (Such materials separated at the dump produce contaminated compost that can’t be used for farms and food crops.)

This decision could also make apartment-dwellers full participants in the city’s Zero Waste efforts rather than excluding them from the city’s comprehensive recycling programs. Students who live in apartment buildings will learn how to properly recycle and compost, as they are expected to do in the Oakland schools, and the city will gain the opportunity for real change in the culture of wasting.


In several months the final contract will come back to the Council for a vote. At that time it will be important to make sure that full implementation of citywide compost service is included for all residences. So far the city has merely asked for a cost estimate; food-scrap collection service at no extra charge will only become a reality if city residents insist on it.

To make sure that you receive our alert when it is time to contact the Council again, go to http://action.sierraclub.org/site/PageNavigator/CHP_SFBay_SignUp. Sign up for “Updates and alerts from the SF Bay Chapter”.

State agency taking steps to make sure polluters pay

Sierra Club California logo.The California state agency responsible for cleaning up contaminated sites, ranging from former military bases to mom-and-pop dry cleaners, has disclosed that it failed to collect clean-up costs from polluters, resulting in taxpayers footing the bill over the years.

The Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), under the leadership of Director Debbie Raphael, conducted an internal investigation that exposed the department’s failure to recoup $185 million in clean-up costs. The problem began and persisted long before Raphael was appointed by Gov. Jerry Brown in 2011.

The department reported that over the 26 years of overseeing clean-ups, the department did not have a good system to bill those who were responsible for the pollution. This resulted in either failed efforts to collect the money or no effort at all in some cases. Previous administrations did not prioritize cost recovery, exacerbating the problem.

“The largest project for which a bill was not sent involved a $9.4 million clean-up of contaminated property owned by the Chemical & Pigment Co. in Bay Point, Contra Costa County,” the Sacramento Bee reported last week.

A question-and-answer document released by DTSC about the clean-up cost recovery said the agency has been working to address the issue, but sees challenges ahead. For instance, a number of sites do not have responsible parties, or the parties have gone into bankruptcy. In those cases, the likelihood of the department being able to collect owed dollars is slim.

The Department noted in the question-and-answer document that it has begun steps to recover clean-up costs. Additionally, the governor appointed a new deputy director of cost recovery, Andrew Kraus III, who has experience in program reviews and audits, to work directly with Raphael on the issue.

Annie Pham

from Sierra Club California Capitol Voice, June 2013

Help make Zero Waste a reality in Oakland!


Update (June 11, 2013): the Oakland City Council will vote on a waste contract on Tue., June 18. Send a message to the Council now at http://action.sierraclub.org/site/Advocacy?pagename=homepage&id=11283; tell the Council to make sure that the new waste-hauling contract includes compost pick-up for all residents!


Oakland apartment dwellers, are you tired of dumping your food scraps in the garbage, when you know they could be turned into compost? Are you sick of getting fewer city services than home-owners? Then get involved with our Oakland Organics Collection Campaign.

In May the Oakland City Council will approve a contract for implementing its new “Zero Waste” trash and recycling collection system, to be implemented in 2015.

At that time the Council will make a key decision: will composting be made available to the 40% of Oakland’s residential units that are in multi-family buildings?

The Sierra Club is teaming up with the East Bay Alliance for a Sustainable Economy and the International Longshore and Warehouse Union to advocate for a robust Zero Waste collection strategy and livable wages for recycling and reclamation workers to help us meet our Zero Waste goals.


To help make sure that all residents and businesses have affordable and equal access to organics collection, join us for an organizing meeting from 6 – 8 pm on Wed., March 27, at 1814 Franklin St., #325; or contact Jess Dervin-Ackerman at jess@sfbaysc.org or (510)848-0800, ext. 304.

As the decision approaches, it is likely that we will be sending out an additional alert to Oakland residents asking you to contact your councilmembers. To be sure of getting the alert, make sure that you are signed up for the Bay Chapter’s e-mail alerts and updates.

International Zero Waste Week – Sunday, March 17 – Friday, March 22, Bay Area locations

Sunday, March 17 – Friday, March 22, Bay Area locations.

In March thousands of jurisdictions and businesses world-wide will be celebrating International Zero Waste Week. Would your agency or firm benefit from sponsoring ZWW activities? Would your town or city like to join the festivities? Would you like to save up to 30% by registering early (by Feb. 14) for the Zero Waste Update? For more information visit www.ncrarecycles.org to learn about Sponsorship Benefits, Preliminary Programs, Tours, Registration, Lodging and Logistics, and ZWW Resolutions.

Zero Waste Update--600 pix copy

International Zero Waste Week is the brainchild of the Northern California Recycling Association (NCRA) and the Zero Waste International Alliance (ZWIA). Assisted by GrassRoots Recycling Network (GRRN), these groups are now seeking sponsors as well as participants. Sponsors receive recognition on all promotional materials, web sites, and signage plus multiple registrations. Sponsorships support event expenses, speaker travel, student scholarships, and the year-round activities of our groups. See the current list and logos below.

In the San Francisco Bay Area, the centerpiece of Zero Waste Week is the Zero Waste Update featuring NCRA’s very popular annual Recycling Update and the Zero Waste International Dialog. Over 450 professionals, local elected officials, advocates, and members of the media will take part in this special two-day event, and hundreds more will take tours and participate in the special activities.

Held in Berkeley on Tuesday, March 19, and Wednesday, March 20, the Zero Waste Update will provide innovative and practical solutions to reduce waste and move toward high diversion and Zero Waste. International case studies will be highlighted, as well as the work of North American communities and agencies on the cutting edge of sustainable materials management.

Registration is now open. Visit the NCRA and GRRN websites for more details or call (510)982-1841. Potential sponsors should visit the GRRN Sponsorship page and then send a note to the ZWIA Planning Committee or call Ruth Abbe at (415)235-1356.

Zero Waste Week 2013 – SF Bay Area

  • Sunday, March 17 – Bay Area Zero Waste Youth Convergence
  • Monday, March 18 – San Francisco Zero Waste Tours and Reception at Fishermans’ Wharf Zero Waste Zone
  • Tuesday, March 19 – NCRA Recycling Update
  • Wednesday, March 20– Zero Waste International Dialog
  • Thursday, March 21– Zero Waste Certification Meeting at Oakland City Hall
  • Friday, March 22 – East Bay Zero Waste Tours and Reception at Urban Ore EcoPark


Zero Waste Week Resolutions

NCRA and ZWIA are encouraging government and industry groups to pass a resolution declaring March 17 – 22 “Zero Waste Week” The goal is to foster support for, create events in alignment with, and/or encourage the adoption of policies supporting Zero Waste in communities worldwide. The sample resolution is posted on the NCRA website as well as actual events and accomplishments. For additional information contact NCRA Vice President Laura McKaughan at lmckaughan@ncrarecycles.org.



Northern California Recycling Association

California Resource Recovery Association

Waste Management of Alameda County and Urban Ore, Inc

HDR Engineering, Pacific Rim Recycling, Recology, Republic Services and USAgain

Altamont Educational Advisory Board, City of Fremont, Central Contra Costa Solid Waste Authority, EcoCycle, Fisherman’s Wharf Community Benefit District, LA Shares, Marin Sanitary Service, Marin County Hazardous & Solid Waste Management JPA, Napa Recycling & Waste Services , PaintCare, R3 Consulting Group, San Francisco Department of the Environment, Sierra Club San Francisco Bay Chapter, and StopWaste.Org


California Product Stewardship Council, Mobius Network LLC, Oakland Zero Waste Program, Reuse Alliance,

SWANA Gold Rush Chapter, Zero Waste San Diego and Zero Waste Sonoma County


Hyatt Fisherman’s Wharf, Amador Valley Industries, LA Shares, Pleasanton Garbage Services,

Sonoma Compost and Tim Flanagan